Skip to main content

Unprocessed E-waste continues to be exported, despite claims otherwise

Electronic Tracking Devices Reveal Violations of Law,
Policies and Public Trust

May 9, 2016. Seattle, Washington. The international toxic trade watchdog organization, Basel Action Network (BAN), released a new report today following a two-year study that involved placing electronic GPS tracking devices into old hazardous electronic equipment such as printers, and computer monitors, and then watching where they travelled across the globe. 

The report, the first to be released from the project is entitled Disconnect: Goodwill and Dell Exporting the Public’s E-waste to Developing Countries, and is released in conjunction with the airing of a PBS NewHour segment entitled The Circuit, as well as an MIT interactive website which graphically shows the overall movement of the tracked devices. 

BAN’s e-Trash Transparency Project so far has delivered 200 trackers across the US to places where the public is likely to take their old electronics to be recycled – such as recyclers and Goodwill stores. The results are in and we now see that instead of being recycled, 65 (32.5%) of these devices, were exported overseas on container ships. Most of them went to Asia, and most were traded in likely violation of the laws of the importing countries. Of the 149 trackers delivered just to recyclers, 39% of these were exported. 

Unfortunately, we are seeing considerable backsliding in the electronics industry today compared to just a few years ago,” said BAN Executive Director Jim Puckett. “Toxic e-waste is flowing off our shores every day to substandard operations, harming people and the environment across the globe. Meanwhile, these exports deprive our own nation of green jobs and make it difficult for responsible electronics recyclers to compete and survive.” 

As a particular focus of the study and the Disconnect report, 46 of the 200 tracker-planted electronic devices were delivered to Goodwill Industries stores across the United States. Seven of these later reported their whereabouts in the Asian countries of Thailand, Taiwan, and China (Mainland and Hong Kong). Six of these were part of Dell, Inc.’s Reconnect partnership with Goodwill. 

Instead of being recycled in the United States as their customers were promised, these devices were exported in violation of Dell’s strict policies, and were likely illegal under the laws of the importing countries. The report takes issue with the fact that Goodwill does not even have a policy against export to developing countries, and Dell surprisingly refuses to tell the public whom their recyclers are. 

Goodwill and Dell, have had strong reputations for social and environmental responsibility. Our findings, however, shake the foundations of that public trust, and cry out for the implementation of immediate reform when it comes to e-waste management,” said Puckett. “These must include stronger, enforced policies of greater due diligence, and transparency.” 

As part of the study, BAN travelled to the locations where the Goodwill and Dell and other trackers ended up, even retrieving one of them. Most arrived in the rural mainland border area, New Territories in Hong Kong. In this area the devices arrived at many informal, outdoor junkyards. These unpermitted facilities exposed illegal immigrant laborers and the environment as the workers smash equipment releasing toxic mercury from the LCD monitors or toxic toners from the printers. 

BAN intends to continue the use of tracking technology, as they believe its use will play a pivotal role in holding an errant and troubled electronics recycling industry to account. They will also make this service available to other civil society organizations, governments, as well as large enterprises.

-- END --

For more information contact

Jim Puckett, Executive Director
Basel Action Network
Phone: +1 206-652-5555
e-Mail: jpuckett@ban.org 

Sarah Westervelt, Electronics Stewardship Policy Director
Basel Action Network
Phone: +1 206-652-5555
e-Mail: swestervelt@ban.org 

Visit e-Trash Transparency Project Page: https://www.ban.org/trash-transparency 

Download the press release by clicking here.

About Basel Action Network 

Founded in 1997, the Basel Action Network is a 501(c)3 charitable organization of the United States, based in Seattle, WA. BAN is the world's only organization focused on confronting the global environmental justice and economic inefficiency of toxic trade and its devastating impacts. Today, BAN serves as the information clearinghouse on the subject of waste trade for journalists, academics, and the general public. Through its investigations, BAN uncovered the tragedy of hazardous electronic waste dumping in developing countries. For more information, see www.BAN.org or blog.BAN.org


How Cascade protects its customers and the environment:
Cascade's e-Stewards certified electronics reuse and recycling process provides the best assurance that our customers' equipment is processed responsibly and that their e-waste won't end up as a tragic incident and news headline. Cascade goes even further than what this standard requires through more on-site due diligence and additional worker health and safety protection programs. Our Safe & Sound programs go beyond compliance with laws and industry standards to ensure we mitigate risk for our customers, our company and our planet.

Through our annual downstream due diligence audits, we review and verify that all our vendors are not accumulating toxic materials and are properly processing them for final reclamation and treatment. Cascade performs a comprehensive audit of its downstream processors who handle hazardous electronic equipment and problematic materials or components. The audit requires the completion of an audit questionnaire, a site visit by Cascade or contracted auditing partner, and a review of claims made by the processor.  Cascade personnel will contact their local environmental regulators, confirm activity with their own downstream processors, and search for public reports of the company.  Cascade then executes a contract, agreement, or shares a listing of requirements with each qualified processor to ensure that both the interests of our customers and our company are protected. 

Cascade has been in business since 1999 and we have never waivered from our commitment to environmental responsibility and social justice. We don't cut corners. We always question the cheap and easy solution because we are more concerned protecting our customers' interest and liability. We have been regularly recognized by the Basel Action Network (BAN), e-Stewards, Gartner, and our peers as one of the leaders in environmental responsibility and safety in the ITAD and electronics recycling industry. Let us show you how our programs align with your business requirements and sustainability goals. Contact us for more details or to set up a visit.